All in Her Head by Jessica Valenti

Share this post
American Moms Are Being Gaslit
jessica.substack.com

American Moms Are Being Gaslit

If staying at home is so wonderful, why don’t men do it?

Jessica Valenti
May 19, 2021
Comment42
Share

The latest ‘discourse’ around motherhood sure sounds familiar. American women, we’re told, are “leaning out,” not having enough children, and not having them early enough in their lives. Oh and child care? It’s not good for kids so one parent should definitely stay home. (I’m sure you can guess which parent they mean.)

It’s frustrating to be 42 years-old and see the same conversations happen over and over again with few signs of progress. It’s especially infuriating when it’s clear why these issues are re-emerging: Since the pandemic started, 2.5 million women have left the workforce, and sexist culture is putting a rosy stay-at-home sheen on a shit-show. 

This is a national emergency, one that will roll back women’s gains in the public sphere by decades—and the response has somehow become about how moms want to be home with their kids anyway. A record number of women have been pushed out of their careers, perhaps irrevocably, but we’re meant to believe that women are fine. Relieved, even. It’s obscene. 

There’s been no comprehensive look at how fathers failed to step up, even when their wives’ jobs were on the line; nor has mainstream media really grappled with how much of a ‘choice’ it is to stay home when your partner won’t do child care or your kids’ school is closed. 

Instead, we’re stuck talking—again—about the supposed benefits of women leaving work. Now, not everyone loves their job. But why, then, isn’t the conversation about making workplaces better rather than women just abandoning them? (Also if your job is underpaid and thankless, I have some news for you about motherhood.)

Most importantly: If staying at home with children is so important and rewarding, why don’t men do it? We all know the answer. 

The truth is that leaving the workforce hurts women. Stay-at-home moms are more likely to be depressed, isolated, and economically vulnerable. And instead of offering financial and systemic support to these mothers, mainstream culture tells them that they should feel fulfilled and fortunate to do “the most important job in the world.” This ensures that women who don’t feel particularly lucky to be working 24/7 changing diapers and wiping noses are often too ashamed to say anything about it. 

Pushing women to stay home doesn’t just hurt those who leave work. Women who remain in their jobs are also harmed by attitudinal shifts that say families are better off with traditional structures. Men with stay-at-home wives are more likely to have negative views of women who work, for example; and we’re already seeing that younger and supposedly ‘progressive’ men have increasingly regressive beliefs about women’s role at home. 

I’m also quite over the idea that it’s just fine if women are erased from public life. I don’t want to live in a country where women’s voices aren’t fully represented in every industry—whether it’s government, media, banks, schools or movie studios. When women aren’t in the room we end up with a world built for men. 

So let’s be clear: Women aren’t leaving the workforce because they want to.  They’re leaving because America has put women, mothers especially, in an impossible situation. They’re leaving because their male partners didn’t do their fair share. 

And despite the culture’s best effort to slickly reimagine this moment as one born of women’s ‘choices’, the truth is far simpler: American women are being gaslit. Being pushed out of our careers is not a good thing, and it is absolutely possible to be a happy working parent, even now. How do I know that parents can ‘have it all’? That it’s actually completely feasible to work and take care of children without giving up your career goals or life ambitions?

Because men do it all the time. 


If you like this column, please subscribe & get pieces like this in your inbox every week!

Comment42
ShareShare

Create your profile

0 subscriptions will be displayed on your profile (edit)

Skip for now

Only paid subscribers can comment on this post

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in

Check your email

For your security, we need to re-authenticate you.

Click the link we sent to , or click here to sign in.

Martha Beard-Duncan
May 27, 2021

I have an egalitarian-minded husband. Unfortunately, senior management at his workplace can't wrap their heads around the concept of a dual-career, two-parent household. Early in the pandemic, they simply did not comprehend our reality: a kindergartner suddenly attending school virtually while both parents attempted to work from home. ‘’What, isn’t it just like homeschooling?” No. And homeschooling wasn’t something we chose.

*My* workplace did NOT handle things much better in early pandemic times. Our chief executive, who is the parent of grown children, sent out an email in which she said that children should just be kept quiet with coloring books while you worked. Which would be laughable had it not been infuriating and unrealistic. Ultimately I did have to use some leave under the CARES act, since neither school nor after-school care were options. I took a paycheck hit for it, too. So, yes, this has laid bare the inequities and I'm feeling pretty raw about it. “Having it all” is an impossible lie if the support isn’t there.

Expand full comment
Reply
Cindy DiTiberio
Writes The Mother Lode ·May 21, 2021

Thank you for this piece. I agree. I have a piece that I am trying to publish somewhere about this situation and my own experience taking a pandemic maternity leave. All this anger and rage began to simmer for me, and I realized that what I did with the pandemic - hitting pause on work to accommodate my family - is exactly what I did when I first had kids. I had just crossed the finish line in August 2019 - my youngest went to kindergarten! I felt like the me I had put up on a shelf for nine years could finally come down. And then it was all ripped away. And I realized that for those nine years, I had wanted more time to work, but didn't feel like I could ask for more. Not because of my husband but because of the inner patriarchy within that made me feel like I should want to mother more than I should want to work. But it wasn't true. I'm not sure I would have realized that except that the raw deal dealt by the pandemic woke me up to my inner rage, unhappiness, frustration with the patriarchy in my own damn mind!

Expand full comment
ReplyGive gift
40 more comments…
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2022 Jessica Valenti
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Publish on Substack Get the app
Substack is the home for great writing